VAT News November 2024

Welcome to November 2024’s edition of VAT news. If you have any questions about the issues below or any other VAT questions please get in touch.

New Officers

It has been announced that there is to be a substantial recruiting programme for HMRC to address the “Tax Gap”. This means that the new resources will be sent out to businesses to ensure that the “right tax is being paid at the right time”.

After many years of reduced resources, a VAT visit can seem as often as a Preston Guild (Google it) or longer but may become much more frequent event for some.

Is your business ready for a VAT inspection? If you’d like an ex-Customs Officer to look at your business to see what challenges and opportunities lie therein, please get in touch.

Businesses Operating in the EU

In early November agreed to adopt the “VAT in the Digital Age” (ViDA) package. This will impact

Digital Reporting Requirements (DRR) – this will introduce standardized reporting and e-invoicing for intra-community supplies;

  • Changes to the place of supply – this is to address issues where a “digital platform” is used to give a “false” place of supply; include
  • Expanding the scope of the One Stop Shop to enable more transactions to be dealt with by a single VAT registration.

The implementation of these changes is due to start in 2027 and complete in 2035, if your business is registered in the EU, you need to understand what steps you need to take.

What is an export?

This may seem simple, but this case took several pages to get to the definition. The deal structure didn’t help either. The taxpayer was a “Reward Recognition Fulfiller”. When a customer became eligible for a reward, they became a “Reward Recipient”. The Reward Recipient received a list of rewards from a Reward Programme Operator (bear with me). The Reward Programme Operator gave the details of the Reward Recipient to the Reward Recognition Fulfiller. HMRC had taken the view that the Reward Programme Operator had taken possession of the reward goods, rather than the Reward Recipient directly, which is very obvious from the summary, and indeed was said to be “entirely fanciful” by the Tribunal.

This appears to be another case where HMRC mis-interpret the transaction, act upon that misinterpretation then fails to reconsider their position before making the taxpayer go to Tribunal.

Section 33

This is a section of the 1994 VAT Act, which enables certain entities to reclaim VAT incurred on costs which are seen as non-business. It’s the section that allows Academy Schools and Local Authorities to reclaim VAT on certain expenditure. It also allows for NHS Trusts to do the same, however, there was a recent case in which an NHS Trust was seen to be making business supplies to a Local Authority. The whole raison d’etre of S33 is that it applies to “non-business” supplies and therefore the method used for recovery was incorrect.

Should already be registered?

The registration gates for fee paying schools to register for VAT have been opened. In making an application the school will need to give an effective date of registration (EDR) and in doing so gives a declaration that HMRC may look to challenge.

The most common reason is where a school has overseas agents that source pupils for them. The fees charged by these agents should carry no local VAT or GST and are subject to the reverse charge in the UK (where the recipient accounts for the output tax and then recovers up to 100% of the input tax). VAT registration rules are such then when the value of reverse chargeable supplies received exceeds the VAT registration threshold (currently £90,000 but £85,000 for several years before that) then the recipient has to register to account for the VAT.

Therefore, one of the first training visit for the new officers (see above) could be visiting newly VAT registered fee paying schools to see if that EDR of 1st January 2025 is right.

Marginal

A number of supplies can be made through what is known as a second-hand or margin scheme. As the name suggests, the VAT payable for the sale is calculated on the profit or margin made by the seller (because there is no VAT to reclaim on the purchase – e.g. an antique bought off a consumer). News reaches us that one such business (a second-hand car dealer) had not reviewed how the purchase price of the cars was calculated, and for many years had been excluding an allowable cost and therefore incorrectly reducing the purchase price and thus increasing the margin that was subject to VAT. Their accountant had not spotted this either. Whilst an adjustment could be made for the last four years (which was in excess of £20,000 due back the dealer) much more had been lost in previous years (outside the timescale for adjustment).

If you make supplies subject to such a scheme and you want the calculations to be independently verified, please get in touch.

Importing in the name of . . .

Not a VAT case but one to chill the marrow of those dealing with imports and exports. A logistics company was based on an industrial estate. Another business on the estate asked a director of the company to arrange for the importation of some “Euro Bins” (the large commercial bins with the roll top lid). This was done but the director acted as the importer in person, giving their name and paying for the movement through their own personal bank account.

When the goods arrived in the UK the consignment was found to also contain a quantity of hand-rolling tobacco. The individual was charged with the duty as the party holding the goods at the first point at which the duty became due.

There was a Tribunal case recently when the individual challenged HMRC’s charges that as she had possession of the goods (not legal title) she was holding the goods for Duty (and penalty) purposes . The Tribunal agreed with HMRC.

The Duty due was £1,206,142 (it was 4,444kg of tobacco), but the penalty was reduced by over £500,000 from £783,992 to £277,412.

Guess Who’s Back. Back again.

There was a County Court hearing for a claim for damages against HMRC. This was a claim for an overpayment of VAT, associated interest and mental injury. The latter had no professional evidence so was dismissed instantly. It then transpired that HMRC had paid the claimant a sum which was seen to include interest. The claimant had not challenged the sum within the 30-day deadline, so this element of the claim also failed.  The claimant was Denis Lunn who ran the accountancy firm Christopher Lunn & Co. Mr Lunn was jailed for 5 years in 2016 for evading £6m in tax. The firm had a number of celebrity clients and it was estimated at the time of the case that there was a further £40m of taxes due from the firm’s clients due to the firm’s activities to artificially reduce their client’s taxes. The total claim made in this case was under £5,000.

The Pitta Patter of HMRC’s feet  . . .

This month also saw an on the run, convicted VAT fraudster caught by HMRC. Robert Kemp and his son were convicted in 2021 but Robert went "on the run" for two years. His downfall? Ordering a kebab to be delivered to his "lair" (i.e. a bedsit in Rhyl).

Apparently HMRC used "Intelligence developed from the order" to establish where Mr Kemp was. Even more obliquely the operational lead said, "we can and do use a range of tools to track down fugitives". The mind boggles, but no doubt international criminals are now deleting their Deliveroo apps as the word spreads.

The amount of the fraud was in excess of £250,000

 

Please note that this newsletter is for information purposes only. It does not constitute, nor should it be seen as a substitute for professional advice. As such AKS Advisers Ltd cannot be held responsible for any actions taken or not taken based on this information.

If you have any questions regarding the above or any other VAT matters, please get in touch.

Ian Marrow

Source: | 09-12-2024